They Said He’d Die in Prison—Now He’s Free
For nearly five decades, Leonard Peltier sat in a federal prison cell, branded by some as a murderer and by others as a symbol of injustice. Presidents came and went. Supporters rallied, celebrities called for his freedom, and human rights organizations pleaded for his release. But year after year, clemency was denied.
Until now.
On February 17, 2025, President Joe Biden granted clemency to the 79-year-old Native American activist, sparking a heated debate that goes far beyond Peltier himself. Some hail it as a long-overdue correction of injustice. Others see it as a political move in an election year. But before we jump to conclusions, let’s rewind to where it all began—on a reservation in South Dakota, nearly 50 years ago.
Contents
The Shootout That Changed Everything
The year was 1975. The Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota was in chaos. The American Indian Movement (AIM), a militant group advocating for Indigenous rights, was in a tense standoff with the U.S. government. The FBI had been monitoring AIM members closely, and violent clashes were frequent.
Then, on June 26, 1975, two FBI agents—Jack Coler and Ronald Williams—were pursuing a robbery suspect on the reservation when they were ambushed. A shootout erupted, leaving both agents dead. The scene was brutal—each had been shot multiple times at close range.
Three AIM members were charged. Two were acquitted after arguing self-defense. The third, Leonard Peltier, was convicted in 1977 and sentenced to two life terms. The evidence? Circumstantial at best. The FBI admitted to withholding key documents, and witnesses later recanted their testimonies, claiming they were coerced.
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1944 | Leonard Peltier is born on September 12 in Grand Forks, North Dakota, and grows up on the Turtle Mountain Indian Reservation. |
| 1972 | Peltier joins the American Indian Movement (AIM), a group advocating for Indigenous rights. |
| 1973 | AIM participates in the 71-day occupation of Wounded Knee, South Dakota, protesting government mistreatment of Native Americans. |
| 1975 | June 26 – A shootout at the Pine Ridge Reservation results in the deaths of FBI agents Jack Coler and Ronald Williams. |
| 1976 | Peltier is arrested in Canada and extradited to the U.S. based on affidavits later found to be false. |
| 1977 | Peltier is convicted of murdering the two FBI agents and sentenced to two life terms in prison. |
| 1980s | Amnesty International and global human rights organizations begin advocating for Peltier’s release, citing unfair trial conditions. |
| 1993 | President Bill Clinton considers clemency but ultimately does not grant it. |
| 2000 | Clinton again reviews Peltier’s case but chooses not to commute his sentence after strong opposition from the FBI. |
| 2009 | President Obama receives petitions for clemency but does not act on them. |
| 2016 | Obama again denies clemency despite widespread calls for Peltier’s release, citing lack of clear evidence of innocence. |
| 2020 | President Trump denies clemency after law enforcement agencies push against Peltier’s release. |
| 2024 | Advocates intensify calls for clemency, citing Peltier’s declining health. |
| 2025 | February 17 – President Joe Biden grants clemency, and Peltier is released from prison a |
A Trial Filled with Controversy
Peltier’s case became a rallying cry for justice reform advocates worldwide. Amnesty International, Nelson Mandela, and even the Dalai Lama called for his release, citing:
• Withheld evidence: The FBI failed to turn over key documents that could have helped Peltier’s defense.
• Coerced witnesses: Two witnesses later admitted they were forced to testify against him.
• An unfair trial: Peltier’s extradition from Canada was based on false affidavits, and his appeals were repeatedly denied.
Despite this, the U.S. government stood firm. The FBI and law enforcement groups insisted that Peltier was guilty and should never be released. Every president from Clinton to Obama to Trump refused to grant him clemency.
So why did Biden do it now?
Why Now? Justice or Politics?
Peltier’s release comes at a pivotal moment. Native American political power is growing, and their votes could be crucial in the 2024 election. By granting clemency, Biden is sending a message to Indigenous communities—a demographic that has long felt ignored by Washington.
But there’s another layer to this. Biden has positioned himself as a champion of criminal justice reform. Peltier’s case is one of the most controversial in modern U.S. history. Was this a genuine act of justice, or a calculated move to strengthen political alliances?
What This Means for the Future
Regardless of where you stand, Peltier’s release will have lasting consequences.
1. Native American Rights Take Center Stage
Peltier’s case has always been bigger than him. It highlights the long history of mistreatment and broken promises between the U.S. government and Indigenous peoples. Expect renewed debates over Native sovereignty and justice reform.
2. The Justice System Faces Tough Questions
Was Peltier a political prisoner or a violent criminal? His trial was riddled with problems, but does that mean he was innocent? His release raises tough questions about due process, prosecutorial misconduct, and fairness in the U.S. justice system.
3. A Political Firestorm Is Brewing
Law enforcement groups are furious. The FBI Agents Association has already condemned Biden’s decision, calling it an insult to those who died in the line of duty. Will this become a wedge issue in the upcoming election?
here are 10 frequently asked questions about Leonard Peltier, along with their answers:
1. Who is Leonard Peltier?
Leonard Peltier is a Native American activist and member of the American Indian Movement (AIM). He was convicted in 1977 for the murders of two FBI agents during a 1975 shootout on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota.
2. What is the American Indian Movement (AIM)?
AIM is a grassroots organization founded in 1968 to address issues of systemic poverty, discrimination, and police brutality against Native Americans. The movement gained national attention through protests and advocacy for Indigenous rights.
3. Why was Leonard Peltier convicted?
Peltier was convicted for the deaths of FBI agents Jack Coler and Ronald Williams during a confrontation on the Pine Ridge Reservation. The conviction has been controversial, with allegations of coerced testimonies and withheld evidence during the trial.
4. Has Leonard Peltier maintained his innocence?
Yes, Peltier has consistently maintained his innocence, stating that he did not kill the FBI agents. He acknowledges being present during the incident but denies being responsible for the deaths.
5. What efforts have been made to secure Peltier’s release?
Over the years, numerous human rights organizations, political figures, and celebrities have advocated for Peltier’s release, citing concerns about the fairness of his trial and his declining health. Notable supporters have included Nelson Mandela, the Dalai Lama, and Amnesty International.
6. What is Leonard Peltier’s current health status?
As of 2025, Peltier is 80 years old and has faced various health issues, including diabetes, high blood pressure, and a heart condition. His health has been a significant factor in renewed calls for his release.
7. What was the outcome of Peltier’s parole hearings?
Peltier has had multiple parole hearings over the years. In July 2024, he was denied parole, with the next full hearing initially set for 2039. However, in January 2025, President Joe Biden commuted his sentence to home confinement.
8. What does commutation of his sentence mean?
Commutation reduces the severity of a sentence. In Peltier’s case, it means he will serve the remainder of his sentence under home confinement rather than in prison. This decision does not overturn his conviction.
9. Where will Leonard Peltier reside after his release?
Following the commutation of his sentence, Peltier is expected to reside on the Turtle Mountain Indian Reservation in North Dakota, where he has familial ties.
10. Why is Leonard Peltier’s case significant?
Peltier’s case has become emblematic of broader issues concerning Indigenous rights, alleged governmental misconduct, and debates over the fairness of the U.S. justice system, especially in cases involving Native American activists.
These questions and answers provide an overview of Leonard Peltier’s case, his background, and the ongoing discussions surrounding his conviction and release.
So, Was Justice Served?
This is where the country remains divided. To some, Peltier is a hero, a symbol of resilience who suffered decades of injustice. To others, he is a cold-blooded killer who should have never walked free.
But here’s the real question: Was his release a victory for justice or a political calculation?
Let’s hear your thoughts. Should Leonard Peltier have been freed? Do you think Biden’s decision was right or wrong? Drop a comment below and join the conversation.
